Can I switch immediately to idle from Engine startup?

Soundmodul für Fahrgeräusche (speziell für RC-Modelle). Der Nachfolger des USM-RC-2
Antworten
david.harrison
Beiträge: 8
Registriert: Fr 1. Dez 2023, 19:16

Can I switch immediately to idle from Engine startup?

Beitrag von david.harrison »

Hello, I am building sound projects for model helicopters. The models are using real helicopter recordings which have a very long turbine engine spool-up time, sometimes 1-2 minutes before they reach "idle speed". The RC operator may get fed up with waiting for the whole of that long spool-up time to pass before he wants to move the throttle stick to increase the motor speed and lift off.

I have found that the whole length of the engine startup time must pass before any movement of the throttle stick is recognised. Can this behaviour be changed to take action immediately when the throttle is increased, even during the engine startup phase? If so, how?

Thank you.
Rascal
Beiträge: 4113
Registriert: Do 9. Okt 2014, 01:31

Re: Can I switch immediately to idle from Engine startup?

Beitrag von Rascal »

Hello David,
The RC operator may get fed up with waiting for the whole of that long spool-up time to pass before he wants to move the throttle stick to increase the motor speed and lift off.
So you don't want to change from startup to idle but from startup directly to FG1 normal, correct?

Try this work-around:
  • Add the same soundfiles as used under Engine sound to Engine sound 2 > Engine sound 2: *
  • Under Configuration > Engine sound > Engine sound 2 select Prop #1 as "Speed from channel:"
  • Select "When starting engine sound 1 or 2, turn off the other"
  • Select "When changing engine sound, skip starting and stopping sound"
  • Select "Turn on engine sound automatically by motion" and set an appropiate time for "And turn off after __ sec. in stationary"
* You don't need to put start and stop sounds for Engine sound 2 since they would be skipped anyway

If Engine sound (1) is switched on the startup sound will be played and eventually change to the idle sound as long as the throttle is not touched. When the throttle is engaged the module will switch off Engine sound (1) and start Engine sound 2.
If the throttle is idle Engine sound 2 will be switched off after the set time and Engine sound (1) will be played again.
I have found that the whole length of the engine startup time must pass before any movement of the throttle stick is recognised.
You mean related to the sound / USM-RC-3 module, or that the motor won't spin up? The behaviour of the module is normal but the latter is not possible since the module is not able to alter the throttle signal if the ESC is connected to Prop #1.
david.harrison
Beiträge: 8
Registriert: Fr 1. Dez 2023, 19:16

Re: Can I switch immediately to idle from Engine startup?

Beitrag von david.harrison »

Sorry, but this solution does not work for me. My main engine sound is not started with motion, but by Prop channel 3. And in the configuration tab for Engine 2, the checkboxes for "When starting engine sound 1 or 2, turn the off the other "and "Turn on engine sound automatically with motion are mutually exclusive." The latter checkbox is greyed out when I check the first checkbox.

It's a pretty ugly workaround, although I couldn't get it to work. It is a pity the Beier engineers didn't think to make the engine startup sound to follow an immediate change to begin with. Of course that is not so much of an issue with very short startup times such as those used for land vehicles, for which the module was primarily designed. But for model helicopters and jet airplanes, the turbine spool-up time can be very long, e.g. up to several minutes, and the RC operator is essentially locked out from making changes to the engine sound until that long startup sound has finished.
Rascal
Beiträge: 4113
Registriert: Do 9. Okt 2014, 01:31

Re: Can I switch immediately to idle from Engine startup?

Beitrag von Rascal »

My main engine sound is not started with motion, but by Prop channel 3.
The idea was to start Engine sound 2 by motion. Anyhow, I overlooked that the options don't work together, so the above work-around is not usable.

Can your transmitter mix the throttle to another channel so that the throttle signal on the slave channel only goes from middle (1,5ms) to full (2,0ms)? If yes see if the following would work for you.

Configure a function sequence (e.g. Function sequence 1) as follows:

fseq.png
fseq.png (63.41 KiB) 1803 mal betrachtet
  • Connect the slave channel to a free prop-channel of the USM-RC-3 (e.g. Prop #4)
  • Configure Prop #4 area A in column "In position (static)" with function "Function sequence 1"
  • First extend area B by pulling the blue square on the left as close as possible to area N, then extend area A towards N, too.
  • Add the same soundfiles as used under Engine sound to Engine sound 2 > Engine sound 2: *
  • Under Configuration > Engine sound > Engine sound 2 select Prop #1 as "Speed from channel:"
  • Select "When starting engine sound 1 or 2, turn off the other"
  • Select "When changing engine sound, skip starting and stopping sound"
* You don't need to put start and stop sounds for Engine sound 2 since they would be skipped anyway.

When the throttle is applied Prop #4 will activate the function sequence, which will start Engine sound 2. Based on the options Engine sound 1 will be switched off automatically then. The f-sequence will stay in the loop as long as the throttle signal falls within area A of Prop #4.
When the throttle goes to 0 the f-sequence exits the loop and switches on Engine sound 1, which will result in Engine sound 2 being switched off automatically.
It is a pity the Beier engineers didn't think to make the engine startup sound to follow an immediate change to begin with.
Well, it's not possible to foresee each and every use case or requirement (expectations, wishes ...) but a lot of functions were actually implemented based on user feedback. You can make suggestions in this forum, e.g. to add an option to "Change immediately to engine sound when throttle is applied" or such. Please formulate the suggestion as detailed as possible.
david.harrison
Beiträge: 8
Registriert: Fr 1. Dez 2023, 19:16

Re: Can I switch immediately to idle from Engine startup?

Beitrag von david.harrison »

Thanks for your reply. While I could probably make this work for myself, it is a far too complicated solution for the majority of my ex-customers for whom I am converting all of my ShockWave 3 sound module .sfx8 soundset files to the BEIER project format. My former business, Model Sounds Inc. has closed due to my retirement, and I am recommending they consider the BEIER USM-RC-3 for their future needs.

I have 41 helicopter sound projects and 110 airplane sound projects to convert.

I have already submitted a feature request to BEIER by email for immediate change to be allowed on the engine startup. Is there a better way of making future requests than sending an email?

Thank you.
Antworten