USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Ihr habt eine Idee, was wir an unseren Produkten noch verbessern könnten, dann lasst es uns wissen
MdG-77
Beiträge: 17
Registriert: Mo 14. Sep 2026, 17:15

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von MdG-77 »

Yes, they are not using the correct way of the Nautic Graupner/Robbe protocol.
In this case, the best choice is to use the PPM1-DS Robbe option, this is more close to the real output.

After connecting the Sbus-DS output directly to my FrSky XE radio I can say they are using the full spectrum 860us to 2140us.
I think all Beier modules have a Sbus limitation from 900 to 2097 ?
So it is hard to see the real value from DS-1 to DS-11 via the Diagnose option.
I know about the Sbus offset with the FrSky radio’s (1480us), I did add an offset in the Mix to compensate this.

Is there a option to change the Sbus limitation in a Test firmware, so I can share the real values which you can use?

About which radio’s are offer this, I need to say I don’t know.
There are some more FlySky radio’s which offer this for sure.

For all EdgeTX and Ethos we can create a LUA for this option!

For my trucks I’m using my LUA (Ethos) and looks like this:
(this LUA uses 2 channels as Source and use both Pads with 16 functions for each Pad)
The Niveau2 function is automatic generated by pressing a single Button (Screen-2 and Screen-4 are the Niveau2 Short functions
IMG_7784.jpeg
IMG_7784.jpeg (1.27 MiB) 971 mal betrachtet
IMG_7787.jpeg
IMG_7787.jpeg (3.68 MiB) 971 mal betrachtet
IMG_7785.jpeg
IMG_7785.jpeg (1.17 MiB) 971 mal betrachtet
Regards,
Marten
Benutzeravatar
BEIER-Electronic Andy
Administrator
Beiträge: 4557
Registriert: Mi 17. Dez 2008, 07:37

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von BEIER-Electronic Andy »

MdG-77 hat geschrieben: ↑Mo 21. Sep 2026, 17:14 Is there a option to change the Sbus limitation in a Test firmware, so I can share the real values which you can use?
That wouldn't actually be necessary. I’m not all that familiar with LUA, but as I understand it, you can set the 11 bits for the S-Bus channel individually and directly—so each switch gets one bit.

In our modules, I can then evaluate those bits directly and individually as well.
MdG-77
Beiträge: 17
Registriert: Mo 14. Sep 2026, 17:15

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von MdG-77 »

If you like to receive the RAW values from the FlySky Paladin EV18 connected to the USM-RC3, then it’s better to read these values with the Diagnose option.
The only thing is, it’s not showing a lower value then 900 and not above 2097, so it’s not possible to see the first and last RAW values.
I will see, if I can make a Sbus reader with a Arduino, to reading the RAW values without any limitations.

For the LUA’s it’s easier to find out the needed values after this is included in the Beier modules.
Via the Diagnose it’s a easy thing to play with this and write down the needed values per DS.
Regards,
Marten
Benutzeravatar
BEIER-Electronic Andy
Administrator
Beiträge: 4557
Registriert: Mi 17. Dez 2008, 07:37

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von BEIER-Electronic Andy »

No, I don't think I need data from the diagnostics. After all, there are 11 switches for 11 bits - so each switch corresponds to one bit of the S-Bus channel - and I can process the bits directly within the module.

Theoretically, then, I can process the switches. I just lack the time to implement it right now, and, I’m not yet sure if there is actually enough demand for it.
MdG-77
Beiträge: 17
Registriert: Mo 14. Sep 2026, 17:15

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von MdG-77 »

Well, I think most people don’t know this option :roll:
For now they can use the PPM1-DS Futaba/Robbe Multiswitch as output.
I sent a message to FlySky about the PPM2-DS Nautic Graupner, that this isn’t the default.
(Yesterday I checked it with a Modellbau-City NauticMC (old version), and works fine except the swapped outputs)

If there was a choice between the 2-position or 3-position, I will use the 2-position (all separate DS functions)
The 3-position Normal mode is like a normal switch, if DS1 is On and I press DS2, then DS1 go’s off.
Other option is to use the DS as a moment/toggle switch and activate the Memory in the Beier.

With the 2-position there is a better overview, which functions are activated.

Feel free to PM me, if you need any more info in the future about this.
Regards,
Marten
Benutzeravatar
BEIER-Electronic Andy
Administrator
Beiträge: 4557
Registriert: Mi 17. Dez 2008, 07:37

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von BEIER-Electronic Andy »

I don't quite understand this section of the FlySky Paladin EV18 manual (page 70):
Note that the starting channel order is 1, 2, 3, 4...18, S1, S2...S8. You can set the appropriate starting channel as needed (set in the binding interface).

For example, if you want to use the S1~S8 digital switch channels, you can set the receiver's starting channel to 15, so that thetransmitter's CH15 corresponds to the receiver's CH1, CH16to CH2...S1 to CH5...S8 to CH12.
I'll get back to you if I have any further questions or anything you could test.
Rascal
Beiträge: 4113
Registriert: Do 9. Okt 2014, 01:31

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von Rascal »

Seems to shift the channels at the receiver so that S1 starts on channel 5 up to S8 on channel 12.

When the starting channel would be set at 11 for example you will then have channels 1-10 in normal order followed by channels 11-18 for the switches S1 to S8.

In the starting channel order (first sentence) S1 to S8 cannot be used since they are "outside" of the 18 channels.
MdG-77
Beiträge: 17
Registriert: Mo 14. Sep 2026, 17:15

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von MdG-77 »

BEIER-Electronic Andy hat geschrieben: ↑Do 24. Sep 2026, 15:20 I don't quite understand this section of the FlySky Paladin EV18 manual (page 70):
Note that the starting channel order is 1, 2, 3, 4...18, S1, S2...S8. You can set the appropriate starting channel as needed (set in the binding interface).

For example, if you want to use the S1~S8 digital switch channels, you can set the receiver's starting channel to 15, so that thetransmitter's CH15 corresponds to the receiver's CH1, CH16 to CH2...S1 to CH5...S8 to CH12.
I'll get back to you if I have any further questions or anything you could test.
Rascal is close with his answer, only channels 17 and 18 are still there in the list to use them (not via the Sbus!)
As far as I understand, when we bind a second receiver and let this one start from 13… (first 12 channels are via receiver-1)
This will look like:
Channel-13 = Receiver output-1
Channel-14 = Receiver output-2
Channel-15 = Receiver output-3
Channel-16 = Receiver output-4
Channel-17 = Receiver output-5
Channel-18 = Receiver output-6
S1 = Receiver output-7
S2 = Receiver output-8
S3 = Receiver output-9
S4 = Receiver output-10
S5 = Receiver output-11
S6 = Receiver output-12

They send a three-state like this:
IMG_0793.jpeg
IMG_0793.jpeg (51.73 KiB) 914 mal betrachtet
And I think they also still sending the DS 1-11 with channel-15 and 12/22 with channel-16 as 11bit. (I will test this)
15 and 16 are not selective in any other Menu options, when we bind it in the 3-position mode.
Regards,
Marten
Benutzeravatar
BEIER-Electronic Andy
Administrator
Beiträge: 4557
Registriert: Mi 17. Dez 2008, 07:37

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von BEIER-Electronic Andy »

Thanks for the explanations; I understand it now.

One more question: Is the Nautic protocol also transmitted directly on one of the S-Bus 16 channels?
MdG-77
Beiträge: 17
Registriert: Mo 14. Sep 2026, 17:15

Re: USM-RC2/3 and SFR support for Graupner DS with radio FlySky Paladin EV18

Beitrag von MdG-77 »

The default Sbus are only channels 1 > 18 and/or S1>S8 without any modulation.
The PPM-DS modulation can only be activated to one of the direct NPA>NPD connections.

I will check if there is anything optional via a Mix option (S1 Mixed to Channel-X and so on)
Regards,
Marten
Antworten